I've never before broached this subject on this blog. Nonetheless, I've always had a strong and consistent position on the matter. I don't have even a marginal interest in ever fathering children.In past conversations with family members and friends on this issue, I've been told that many people who are opposed to the idea of having children as young adults tend to become more receptive to the notion as they grow older. Perhaps that's true, but I'm unconvinced it will be the case for me. I realize this may limit my prospects for finding a future spouse, since many women do desire to have children at some point in their lives. I find this deeply regrettable, but I can't compromise my personal opinion on that basis alone. After all, differing perspectives on the possibility of parenthood isn't necessarily a deal-breaker for marriage.
There are several reasons why I don't understand the appeal of having children. I do realize the joy and fulfillment that it can bring — but from my point of view, this is far outweighed by the indescribably enormous responsibility, stress, and loss of freedom that it entails. I've observed an increasing number of people my age who have had a baby and abruptly given up their youth — some of the best years of their lives, and years that will never return. Suddenly, going out for drinks, dinner, or a movie becomes an ordeal because they can't find a babysitter. The ability to travel is greatly limited. Spontaneous activity becomes almost impossible. Twenty- and thirty-somethings who once loved to spend time with friends outside of work suddenly need to go straight home to watch their kids. They're the ones who often barely made ends meet before parenthood; add children to the equation, and it'll be years before they have any money saved.
Yes, children are a massive financial commitment. But they're an equally huge commitment of time and emotion. The notion of fathering a child fills me with anxiety — anxiety over the reality that I'd be responsible for the very survival and development of another human being for at least the next two decades of my life. The responsibility of parenting a child is unlike any other; it isn't simply a job you take care of, move on and forget about. It's a job in which you spend every waking hour worrying about every facet of your son's or daughter's life. And in the current state of this world, I'd have serious reservations about bringing another person into it. What kind of conditions will he or she face as an adult? The thought sometimes makes me shutter. Some might call me a pessimist for this reason; I'd prefer to describe myself as a realist.
Some might also read this and conclude two other things: 1) that I'm selfish; and 2) that I'm ignorantly and inaccurately painting parenthood in a purely negative light. On the first point, I'd argue the opposite: It's selfish to bear children and then decide that you don't want the responsibility, stress, or loss of freedom. Making that determination ahead of time is simply a smart choice. On the second point, I'll again concede that parenthood can be a joyful and rewarding experience. In fact, I'm convinced it is — otherwise, no one would choose to raise children. What might be perceived as a negative tone is simply the point of view of someone who has always viewed parenthood with deep reluctance. Nevertheless, I'm not so confident in my own intellect as to presume that I'll never change my tone on this matter. It isn't likely — but I've learned that when I try to shut doors on possibilities for myself, life sometimes has a way of forcing them open. I will find out.
12 comments:
Peter, I love you dearly, but please explain to me what you plan to do with this... freedom.
I think more and more in our generation feel this way than in the past. I think the social norm of having kids is slowly changing to one where it is normal to have or not.
Parenthood is definitely sacrificial, but, speaking as a Christian, I believe that it is only through sacrifice that we are blessed with new life. It is unwise, at a young age, to built barriers against future possibilities. Let life take its course and see what happens.
Stosh in Illinois
Another reason why I think I'll love being an aunt instead of a mother. I don't have the financial commitment, I get to have the emotional connection of loving a kid, that isn't mine, and I don't have to take on the responsibility that comes with being a parent.
I'm in a similar position at this stage in life too. I don't know if I want kids eventually or not. I'm against me having my own biological children through natural childbirth methods. But with technological advancements, that can be avoided. I think there are enough children in this world already who need loving caring parents, and are stuck in foster care systems, that I think if I decide someday that I want kids, I'll adopt. Even if I'm able to from a biological standpoint, which people seem to not really understand why i'd want to raise someone else's kid if I could have my own, but that's part of the beauty and horror we have of choosing to be parents or not.
And it doesn't end after even a quarter century ... when they leave the house you have to read their blogs and make sure they aren't having idiotic thoughts. You know, I raised two and it wasn't so much a problem. I remember dragging kids around with me as I travelled in Europe and the U.S.. I remember taking kids to theater and restaurants and dinner. I remember also going those places without them by just making a phone call and getting a sitter (or my beloved husband) to watch the kids while I went out with my friends. I even managed to survive financially while doing it. I didn't want kids when I was 25. But life surprised me and now I regard it as the best thing I did in my life. That freedom you cherish does evolve as you get older. Don't get me wrong. I agree that not everybody should have kids--heck, maybe most people shouldn't. But I do know one person who deserves grandkids ... Guess who.
The notion that "the current state of the world" argues for avoiding parenthood is particularly lame. When has the world not been in a bad state? One could argue, in fact, that things are a lot better now than they were in the Dark Ages, Middle Ages, the World Wars era, etc. If people, in general, bought the notion of avoiding child-bearing until most of the world's problems were solved, the human race would have died off centuries ago.
Stosh in Illinois/ Anonymous, you are a wise woman. I appreciate your comments as someone older and wiser by experience. Will you write a blog? :-)
Can't quite let this go, which surprises me. In general I am a zpg (zero population growth) advocate and an un-sentimental type, but here goes.
In 1981 I graduated at the top of my law school class, got a job at the best-paying law firm in Chicago, and got married. I was totally committed to career, zpg, and not having kids. A year later, I got the news that my mother, then 47, had lung cancer and was told she had 6 mos, max, to live. I spiraled down into depression. I really wondered about the purpose of life. My new job, maximizing profits for big corporate clients, meant nothing. I was like a zombie. I then learned, much to my shock, that I was pregnant. We didn't own a house, we were drowning in debt (student loans), and we had no idea how to cope. Didn't matter. Miracle happened: big blond, smiling baby boy. My mother lived another 6 years just to watch him. I learned that jobs and debt and money and all of that are pretty irrelevant. This baby was an anchor for my family in a storm and I hate to think what I would have missed without him, including finding Iowa City, visiting central Europe and Seattle, meeting many fine young people .... Not necessarily relevant to you, but my point is: don't be so arrogant as to assume what is meant for the rest of your life. Stay open to what is meant to be.
PS, ZPG = zero population growth
The undeniable joy of having the freedom to go out with friends for a brew whenever we want tends to grow old as we grow older. By the time we are in our 30's or 40's, we long for something more meaningful in which to center our lives. For many, this leads to marriage and parenthood. This entails sacrifice, but also unexpected joys. Don't knock it unless you try it.
Eleni
There is no love as unconditional and selfless as that of a good parent. When your child hurts, you hurt. When your child is happy, you're happy. No human love is more like the love of God. Perhaps that's why God wants most of us to be parents: to give us the experience of what it is to love like Him. To be afraid of committing to such a love and all it involves is understandable, but to rule it out is selfish.
Stosh in Illinois
I too used to have no desire to bear children. At 24, I’m hardly past my prime, but as I’ve gotten older and grown up, my attitude has changed completely for several reasons. First of all, two of my best friends and mentors are in their 50s, and both are half of a childless couple. Both of these friends are simply fantastic people, and I think they would have made great parents. In fact, sometimes they end up playing a parent role for me, both because I need the guidance and because they need a “child” to share their wisdom with. Secondly, it’s pretty clear that less-educated people tend to have more children (of course not all the time, but it’s a trend). We need more well-educated people bringing up more well-educated children! My parents gave me some pretty awesome genes – I feel I should pass them on. Thirdly, I find extreme joy in doing things for others; I don’t think I could live just for myself forever. I don’t see the sacrifices we make for our children as a loss, but rather as an investment in the future.
All that said, I guess I’m not really adamant that I actually bear a child. I could adopt, too. Because Susan is right, there are a lot of children already in the world who need good parents. I guess my point is more that raising children is something that I have come to see as a necessary part of my future.
“Anonymous” Mother from Chicago – you are a real inspiration. I’m serious. I’ve spent a lot of time mulling over the logistics of having a child – particularly the financial aspects – and your story has helped me to see that while I can plan all I want, sometimes life surprises you, but no matter what happens things will work out in the end. Just look at the great results you got! :)
Post a Comment